[drc]

My opinion is they're both nice items. The Hoboken is more documentably baseball than the other. The other (Mathew Brady CDV of Sam and Harry) was ambiguous.

I wouldn't label either as a baseball card, though the Hoboken ticket is getting very close. If the tickets were designed to be kept as a mementos, then I'd say its very very close. And putting a photo of the players on front, sure makes the appear to be be designed as collectables. So I can understand if someone calls the Hoboken a baseball card, even if I call it a ticket.