Quote:
Originally Posted by Brian Van Horn
Other players for consideration:
Baby Doll Jacobson
Charlie Grimm
Emil Meusel
Bob Meusel
Stuffy McInnis
Bob Veach
Bob Johnson
|
You have pretty low HOF standards, IMHO.
Baby Doll Jacobson? Career 112 OPS+, less than 100 HRs, and only 1700 hits.
Charlie Grimm? A 1B with a career OPS+ of just 94?!? Has a much stronger case as a manager and absolutely zero case as a player.
Emil Meusel? Simply didn't play enough. 9 seasons (discounting his 1 game in 1914 and 42 in 1927) just ain't enough. And he wasn't elite in those 9 seasons.
Bob Muesel? Decent enough candidate though he also didn't really play long enough. Just 11 years, none of which were GREAT by the standards of the day. With a higher peak, maybe he gets in.
Stuffy McInnis? A 1B with a career .381 slugging percentage? Even by dead ball era standards, that's terrible.
Bobby Veach? This one's a pretty solid pick. The Hall isn't incomplete by his absence but he is a much better candidate than I expected when I looked him up. Certainly a lot better than some of the other guys on this list.
Bob Johnson? Yep. Hurt by being in the shadow of other, greater players of the era but he probably belongs.