The disconnect comes from what the collector values. I would take factory errors over post factory errors when given a choice. Other collectors (a lot actually) care about centering and a card can be flawed in other ways but pay a premium if it is centered, especially if it is an issue difficult to find well centered.
Others will not pay for writing on a card, but if it is a stamp or other "period" markings they may actually bring a premium to some collectors.
You really have to look past the grade and look at the cards to see where the prices are coming from.
|