Quote:
	
	
		| 
					Originally Posted by kmac32  And who is third on the list of all time saves in MLB?  Wasn't Sutter or Eckersley last time I checked.  Believe the order is Hoffman, Rivera, Smith.  Don't see Sutter or Eckersley in the top 5 of the  list.  Sutter is 26th on the list with 300 saves and Eckersley is 6th with 390 saves.  Smith had 478 career saves.  The numbers speak for themselves. | 
	
 Saves are a worthless stat. 
Basically, you're saying, of all the relievers who played from 1980-1997 and finished with exactly 478 saves, Lee Smith was the premier guy. I certainly can't argue with that. 
Premier closers put up sub-2.00 ERA seasons.  Smith did that once.   But he did have 13 over 3.00 - a by-no-means great number for a closer.