What Would You do? '55 Topps Clemente
I recently won a 1955 Topps Clemente PSA 2.5 on Ebay from Probstein. I thought it was a fair price and the card looks good for the grade. When I received last night, I noticed where the right side has been tampered with in 2 locations (right beside the label). In both places, the plastic is actually cracked slightly. I've included pictures below. The card appears to be totally legit in my opinion and again really nice for the grade. My questions is ... would you return it for a refund? Or accept it the way it is and get it regraded? Or leave it as is? I like the card but the tampering bothers me. I understand I take some liability for bidding on a Probstein auction in the first place! I respect this boards opinion and would truly appreciate any insight from you guys. Thanks for looking.
|