I've tried to find some other players and identify them and have names on three players - but they are shots in the dark--- but figured I'd throw it out there. Here is the roster (going with the 1885 theory): Dan Casey, Chub Collins, Sam Crane, Jim Donnelly, Jim Keenan, Deacon McGuire, Larry McKeon, Mox McQuery, Cyclone Miller, Gene Moriarty, Miah Murray, Tom Poorman, Sam Thompson (HOF)
Dan Casey
Dan_Casey2.jpg
Mox Mcquery
Mox_McQuery.jpg
Sam Crane
Samcrane.jpg