In the OP, I believe the one on the Left is a forger copy of the REA auction posted further below. I would love to see the full medium that the autograph is on. If it is simply a "cut", I would feel very confident.
As for the one on the right, Klrdds knows more about Chadwick than I do. I know the autograph originated from the 1991 DuMouchelle auction and there was no clear idea where those autographs originated from, but there was some beautiful autographs sold for crazy (1991) prices. Everything was deemed authentic, as there was no real internet then to compare autographs to, and obviously no TPAs.
IMHO, I personally was never a fan of that version simply because they don't match the material released from his great-grandson in 2013....but I could be very wrong.
Again, just my 2 cents.
|