Quote:
Originally Posted by butchie_t
Shoeless Joe took the money, no pass from me.
Pete Rose gambled on his team to win, no pass from me.
Pick anyone from the Houston Astros a couple of years ago. They all should be banned. No pass from me.
:shrug:
B. T.
|
Astros, yes, 100% should be banned. That immunity garbage MLB gave them is a joke.
Rose, he supposedly never tried to throw a game and lose, which is really what the gambling rule was put in place to stop. But it was and still is the rule, and Rose knew it. So agree as well.
Jackson my be a little more complicated. To this day, no one really knows exactly everything that occurred. There is evidence that Jackson didn't necessarily willingly agree to accept and keep the money, and supposedly the money primarily went to benefit a sick relative in need of surgery and care. His stats and play during the 1919 WS certainly seem to belie the argument that he was actively trying to throw the WS. And there was no specific gambling rule in place at that time for MLB as there is today. So Jackson was permanently banned by the retroactive application of a rule that didn't exist at the time of the alleged transgression. I'd love to see how that would have held up in today's courts, and how fast the lawsuits to stop it would have been filed. Not so sure Jackson was fairly treated by MLB back then, which had their own agenda they were keeping to at the time.