Thread: PSA re-grade?
View Single Post
  #1  
Old 06-16-2022, 07:55 PM
jh691626 jh691626 is offline
Jeff H
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2021
Location: Massachusetts
Posts: 459
Default PSA re-grade?

Hi all--

I am sure there has already been a thread on this, and also I think I know the right answer. I think you need to just talk me down.

I recently purchased a card slabbed in a PSA 5 holder. It REALLLY looks nicer than a PSA 5, like a PSA 7 or 8. An increase in grade to PSA 6 would be worth the cost of grading for sure, to PSA 5.5 would still be worth it too, though much closer.

I am definitely not taking it out of the holder (too much of a risk of it going down, even as nice as it looks, and I would probably mess things up). So it would go in, in the holder.

The question is: should I get it re-graded? I imagine the answer is, "it depends on the situation, but probably not and especially not in the holder." But would be interested in anyone's experience with getting cards re-graded in this way.

I'd rather not post the card for a variety of reasons (it's not SO valuable) given all the scammer talk lately, but if anyone is curious, please PM me and happy to share.

Thanks for any advice! Jeff
Reply With Quote