Wow! While I could see that the Bonds forgery was among the worst I've ever encountered, I struggled to make any sense of the other autograph!
I've examined countless Mays items, authentic and otherwise, and I wasn't seeing Mays there! That's how poor the forgery is. Besides the humorous letter formations, I was definitely thrown off by that chasm of a space between his first and last names and the two separate photos of first and last names. Guessing it would have been made more apparent to me if the item was in front of me. With "Bonds" and "Mays" on the same item, ball in hand, it would have been less of a facepalm moment!
My initial thought was, "Someone was trying to forge
Juan Pierre?!".
It's pretty rare that a forgery is so pitifully executed that I can't discern who they're trying to rip you off with! Kudos for figuring it out.