Positional dominance does matter but as I pointed out Salvador Perez led the league in both categories as recently as 2021 and finished 7th. Raleigh has more home runs but I don’t think that makes him the MVP over Judge, who is dominating the league in every other offensive category. Since I don’t think Raleigh is a Pudge level catcher on top of his offense I think his case rests largely on his bat. And I think Judge has the superior bat.
Last edited by packs; 09-13-2025 at 07:23 AM.
|