These guys are making it tough to pick. Both on fire down the stretch with Raleigh closing in on Judge’s AL Record with 4 games left to play.
Meanwhile Judge becomes the 1st Non-Peds guy since Ruth to hit 50+ 4 Times in his career.
Judge has the Offensive Analytics and WAR metric heavily in his favor, and Raleigh has the traditional power numbers, offensive catcher records, and a reputation as a stellar defensive catcher (even though the metrics don’t quite agree for this year) in his favor.