Posted By:
petecldMy 2 cents:
• Any card with ANY paper loss can't be "ex".
The best grade I have ever received for a card with back damage is a E98 Mathewson SGC 40. I would personally like a higher grade since the front looks so (gosh darn) nice but I can't argue the grade. It's fair.
The grade on the Hornsby was influenced by who the submitter was, not the condition of the card.