Posted By:
Rob M (ramram)Scott - A good compilation of records and stats for the period of your interest is in Marshall D. Wright's "The National Association of Base Ball Players, 1857 - 1870". It is nothing but 300+ pages of stats. Each chapter covers a full year and every team in the Association (which, of coarse, included about any team worth mentioning) for which he could dig up information. It includes game by game results also.