[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Baran

Hal,

You could easily argue that the Mayo IS Nichols ROOKIE card. The Old Judge card lists him as a minor leaguer. For this reason, I have the Mayo rather than the Old Judge as well.

I know lots of you non-rookie card collectors think these conversations are silly, be we love these debates.

P.S. Wait till I show you what Rookie Card I am purchasing privately