Posted By:
Rob LBased on the original question of the best deadball era pitcher, the total is:
14 - Walter Johnson
1 - Cy Young
1 - Ed Walsh
In terms of the top three, the general consensus appears to be:
1. Walter Johnson
2. Christy Mathewson
3. Cy Young
Since Walter Johnson was the overwhelming choice and an apparent no brainer, I think I will take Chris' suggestion to see if we can get more of a debate going. A new survey question will be on the way.