Posted By:
Jay MillerAdam--You did a great job for Dan. Dan, congratulations on getting the issue resolved.
Now Adam, let me ask you a theoretical question. Dan is an honest guy. Suppose there was a guy who wasn't honest. Suppose that guy sent one submission to PSA but claimed he had sent two and the "missing one" contained a valuable card that he had legitimately purchased in the past (he still had that card hidden away). Since the basic facts would have been the same as this case--submitter claims he sent two submissions and one, containing a valuable card, was lost---PSA claims it got only one submission in the box--would the court have reached the same decision which, in this hypothetical case, would have been wrong. I guess what I am asking is isn't this really just a he said, she said case.