[Archive]

Posted By: Gilbert Maines

These lists are always a source of much opinion and fruitless debate. Although we all recognize this, it is still difficult to not put your two cents in.

I will now fall into the temptation:

While arguement can be made for inclusion of hitters listed 1-5 in a top ten list, there is no apparent justification for grading Mantle above either Cobb or Foxx.