Posted By:
Hal LewisWhat you guys are saying doesn't make sense, because PSA does not sell cards to anyone.
Therefore, ANYONE who has EVER bought a slabbed card has bought it from someone OTHER than PSA... and therefore technically has no "privity."
SO... if what you are saying is correct... then EVERY slab is worthless because they only "attach" to the person who submitted the card to PSA?
If this was possible, then PSA could slab 100,000 reprints as authentic cards for someone... and then that person could sell them for $10,000,000... and NOBODY would be responsible?
Do you think PSA could say to 100,000 people: "Sorry, you can't sue us because you were not the original submitter."?
And the seller could say, "Sorry, I sold you a graded and authenticated card as-is, so you got what you got."?
If PSA was like that, they would have gone out of business a long time ago.
I think they do a great job of standing behing their service.
Didn't SGC do the same thing when Keith Olbermann bought a rare card that turned out to be slabbed wrong?? Didn't they PAY the PRICE of the card and NOT just offer the $15 grading fee refund? They didn't argue privity, etc., and neither would PSA.