Posted By:
Bottom of the NinthMike,
Sadly I have had very poor results with getting PSA to ever buy back cards. With respect to the group of cards you refer to, my relationship with Joe was already strained. I think Joe figured I was just trying to start more trouble and ignored my emails about the group of cards I had. This was not the first time I had presented executives at PSA with cards in holders that I felt were either misgraded or altered.
I don't want to slam PSA too hard here but I was the one who submitted most of the cards over a 3 or 4 month period during what I thought was a terrible time in the grading room. Most of the cards were not that significant, although there were a few that were. The cards were submitted to make a point, which I never got to make. I held the cards for a few months after the email to Joe, scanned all of them and broke them out of the holders. The cards were traded (as altered) to a dealer who sells lower graded material. I decided not to continue my crusade as I was inviting far more trouble in my life than it was worth.
Greg