Posted By:
peter chaoJohn,
I'll assume that although there was paper loss the card wasn't marked. If that's the case, the bidder got a good deal, but the card sold for just below market. But you did not miss out on a great deal.
I got a good deal for a '48 Bowman Y. Berra rookie card for $150. This card was centered and pretty, however, there was a pinhole on the top border. Similar type situation like you were describing. I also consider this card right below market price.
Peter