Posted By:
Dan BrettaIt looks like the same card to me from the tiny bit of registration problems on his shoulders to the bit of blue ink that bleeds out on the bottom border...the image appears to come out of the border on the lower left on both cards as well. I think it's a legit picture of "The Card".
edited to add - just looking at the blown up scan of the PSA 8 Wagner you can see that it is obviously trimmed by looking at all 4 corners. Pull a new Topps card out of a pack and look to see if the corners flare out like that.