Posted By:
Scott M.Hi Steve,
I appreciate the detective work that you did in comparing your scan with the scan of the card in question but I would caution that unless you have two scans taken with the same scanner and same resolution then you can't really be sure that your scans are on the same scale.
For arguments sake, here is a scan of my T205 Cobb scanned at 300 dpi and pasted over the initial picture of the card in question. The only thing I've done with the initial picture is to rotate it to the right to straighten it out and then paste the image of my T205 Cobb to the right of it.
I'm not saying that you couldn't be correct and the card in question might be counterfeit but I don't think you can make this determination based simply on comparing it to a scan of another card.
In case anyone is curious, here is the front of the card I used in the comparison above...
http://www.sgccardregistry.com/images.asp?cardid=43849&usetid=1778