[Archive]

Posted By: nbrazil

Bear with me...

I'm a numbers guy and like to frame ideas and thoughts in data. There has been a lot of talk on these boards about how one grading company is better than another. What do these opinions look like from a numerical perspective?

From a scale of 1 to 10, rate the following grading companies according to your confidence in the company's ability to correctly grade pre war cards. A one represents no confidence whatsoever...I would NEVER send a pre war card to this company. A 10 represents 100% confidence...I would not hesitate to have any pre war card sent to this company for grading. A five represents neutrality...I have some confidence in the company's ability to correctly grade a pre war card, but have an equal amount of reservation.

Here are the companies...

BVG
GAI
PSA
SGC

Once I get a critical mass of responses, I'll summarize how the board, from a numerical perspective, feels about each company. This is not meant to be scientific in any sense of the word...just personal curiosity.