Posted By: 
WesleyI hope I am not violating the VCP TOS by posting this, but a PSA 8 Colgan Chip Wagner sold for $2442 and a SGC 88 Colgan Chip Wagner sold recently on ebay for $2550.  By contrast, the SGC 88 TIn Top Wagner sold last night for $8907.
The last PSA 8 Cobb sold over one year ago for $1851.  The SGC 88 Tin Top Cobb sold last night for $11858.
With identicles front images, the Tin Tops are certainly not worth 5 to 6x more than the regular Colgans to me.  But then again, I have never been especially fond of the Colgan Chips either.