[Archive]

Posted By: boxingcardman

You still don't know who they were, how they chose, or whether they were even mentally competent at the time of the vote. Some of these voters were the same tools responsible for HOFers Jesse Haines, George Kelly and Rabbit Maranville. Their current incarnations have given golden gloves to players who didn't even play 100 games at the position. Again, a vote isn't good for anything except picking the winner of the particular contest. If you want to prove a fact, argue facts, not someone else's interpretation of some unknown set of facts.

Ruth and Williams are basically neck and neck as the most productive, non-druggie, hitters of all time. Ruth was a crisp fielder with a great arm and a HOF caliber pitcher. In his breakout performances at eah position he set the consective shutout innings record in the world series and hit more home runs by himself than any other team in the league. He was incomparable.

Sic Gorgiamus Allos Subjectatos Nunc