[Archive]

Posted By: Anonymous

Matt- With all due respect, you know very little with regard to grading and how to detect trimming. Like Steve, I also never said that the Ruth was definitely trimmed (like Steve said, only 3 people did, not "everyone" like you claim), but there is an inconsistency along the bottom right border that is unmistakeable. You're confusing the opinions of the three people that told you the card is definitely trimmed with everybody else's. Everybody else was telling you that PSA generally doesn't cross over GAI cards in the slab, so either crack it or send it to SGC.

You pretty much blew your credibility when you claimed that this Gwynn RC is perfect in every way, and you can't see any flaws and were flabergasted when it didn't come back a perfect 10. Even after people pointed out that it is off center, has four touched corners and chipping along both side edges, you still claim to not see these flaws.




Your eyes and experience in grading aren't exactly to be trusted, so I'll say again, maybe you should take in the advice of others instead of being stubborn and refusing any opinions that may differ from your own.