Hobby convention is that when the name on a card incorrectly identifies the image of the player shown on the card, then the photo determines whose card it is. For example, in the Old Judge set, the cards picturing Leech Maskrey that misidentify him as James Macullar are Leech Maskrey cards. With that in mind, I wonder why grading services continue to identify the Yum Yum card which pictures Abner Dalrymple (but misidentifies him as Cap Anson) as a Cap Anson card.
http://www.tonyetrade.com/ImageViewe...30&CompanyID=1