I would put Mazeroski at 2B over McPhee. I would argue Haines or Rixey at SP. Waite Hoyt didn't have an overwhelming career either, but did have great postseason success.
Not sure about the defense factor, but Ray Schalk can be argued at C.
I personally feel Hack Wilson is overrated. He had 5 "HOF" type years, possibly only 3 can be argued. His career numbers are nowhere near HOF worthy.
EDITED TO ADD: Agree with Peter's additions to the SP staff
Last edited by Robextend; 01-17-2011 at 07:21 PM.
|