[Archive]

Posted By: Mark

As a collector (and speaking from a collector's perspective) I would NEVER buy a retouched or traced autograph. It would hold "zero" appeal to me. I would rather have a vintage original signature that grades a "1" than a restored signature that grades a "10".

Even beyond autographs, I believe that vintage collectibles should remain in their original state. The only restoration that I personally find acceptable is on Posters, Broadsides, Ad Signs and related artwork- and that would be the type of restoration that prevents condition from worsening (ie decay from water damage, edge tears extending, etc.) And even that type of restoration must be fully disclosed by the seller or auction house, IMO.