[Archive]

Posted By: Joann

I agree, Jim. I'm not sure an exception was made either. I think the grade probably got at least some discussion at PSA given what card it is. (Am I being incredibly naive with that assumption? Just seems to make sense to me.) I think a 5 is generous, and also think a 4 is not at all out of line. But an SGC 30 would be more out of line (at least the way I look at grading) than the 5.

It could have gotten the tip from 4 to 5 based on submittor. Maybe, maybe not. It's definitely a good possibility, but at least the 5 is arguable. Several here have made the argument in favor of a 5 (or at least in favor of it being close), so I guess PSA could too.

J