[Archive]

Posted By: T206Collector

You leave out the most salient distinction between Magie/Doyle and the others: Magie/Doyle were errors made by the creators of the cards -- typographic errors -- that were negligently created and then subsequently intentionally edited. The others were caused by flaws in the actual printing process and thus much less interesting to me (and many other) T206 collectors. Lumping them all in as the same kind of printing error is not a persuasive basis upon which to claim that Magie and Doyle do not belong on the checklist. I own a Magie, with an "I" -- it is a different card with a different name than the Magee that shares its portrait. Nodgrass lost his S because of a flaw in the printing process itself and is more akin to a bubble on the paint of a card.