If based strictly on batting:
Pete Browning
Babe Herman
Riggs Stephenson
Other players for consideration:
Baby Doll Jacobson
Charlie Grimm
Emil Meusel
Bob Meusel
Stuffy McInnis
Bob Veach
Bob Johnson
Pitchers:
Tommy John
Tony Mullane
Jim McCormick
Both player and pitcher:
Kid Gleason (over 1900 hits and 138 wins)
|