Quote:
Originally Posted by PolarBear
Really interesting question. I guess it depends on how you define things.
I don't think issues like R312 are "cards" so so me personally, I wouldn't include them.
Also, Zeenut is a minor league card, so I personally wouldn't include that either.
Then it gets a little tougher to decide. Should foreign issues count? Is Canada "foreign"?
I'm not sure how I would answer that. If you're ok with a "foreign" card, then I think 1936WWG is the rookie. If not, then 38 Goudey.
But, the 38 Goudy is such a stupid looking card, I'd never buy one.
If I wanted a DiMaggio, what I'd personally get is one of the Play Ball issues.
|
I'm following Don on this one. Agreed the 1938 is a mainstream issue but I consider the 1939 Playball as his rookie when I bought mine. This could spark a great debate, but ultimately in comes down to minor vs major league issue and what people consider mainstream issues cards.