1953 Paige was one I was going to suggest. I do not like 1953 Topps but I had to have one of them. I'd also go with:
1952 Topps Gus Zernial
1953 Bowman Mantle
1953 Bowman Musial
1961 Topps Maris
1971 Topps Munson
1972 Topps Clemente
And of course, the 1972 Topps Billy Martin
