The reveal
As Nicolo through his technical prowess already revealed the PSA grade, here are the cards with the grades intact.
This was a VERY interesting exercise to me. Particularly that there was actually a difference of opinion about which card deserves the higher grade!
To me as to most of the responders visually the PSA card appears about a grade better than the SGC card. I own the PSA card.
Would love to continue the discussion as to what factors led to your responses. What I see - PSA has stronger centering, PSA has stronger color, PSA has stronger edges (almost no chipping), PSA has slightly better corners. There was a comment about focus - I don't see a difference - others? The only thing I see that the SGC wins - it doesn't have the tiny print dot on Matty's nose that the PSA one has.
It came up as I was asked to trade The PSA for the SGC + cash. It was 8.5% in cash of what I was asking on the Matty. I refused the offer as to me whatever the #, my PSA card just has eye appeal a full grade higher than the SGC. So for those of you who see the PSA as nicer than the SGC - what would you figure to be a fair % premium if you were trading down to the SGC? Feel free to use numbers if easier. They are both Sovereign backs.
|