not sure who specifically said this??
"Even if they are period that dose not make them Buchners. You keep drawing a clear line saying they are Gold Coins cut from a Buchner Ad."
Maybe someone else - I'm not going back again. I feel that they are old and original representations of a base ball player in similar design to the Gold Coin issues. I'm sorry if I ever gave any other impression. My smoker's heads from Goodwin/Old Judge had two different lithographers. THERE ARE SUBTLE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THEM but they ostensibly look the same.
Whether they were found together or not only adds a tiny bit of "provenance" or reliability to the equation of real or contrived. For me an actual connection for that player to a Gold Coin product would be necessary to call it a Gold Coin anything.....
|