Posted By:
JimBKelly,
On the one hand, it appears you are right with regards to ex or higher. If we limit it to nm or higher both Dockman and E93 have 59 graded examples by PSA. They are exactly equal. The numbers are different for Dockmans in SGC holders but my guess is that that is because Mastro had a high grade set of E93s all graded by SGC. The buyer of that lot then crossed a bunch of previously PSA graded nm and above cards to SGC to match his set. Part of our difference may be in definition of high grade. I think it is reasonable to consider ex and above high-grade for any caramel set, perhaps you are right. If we push the envelop to ex/mt or nm, the discrepancy shrinks.
Best,
JimB