Scenario
Barring any other facts I think the seller was fair in offering a full refund over a partial refund. The condition of the card and hence its value was subjective and a matter of opinion between buyer/seller. He obviously thought the card was worth more in the indicated condition and may be able to get it in another auction. Offering a full refund and getting the card back gives him this option.
I have been in similar situations as a buyer and I empathize with you. However, I think the seller was fair.
Z Wheat
|