Posted By:
HankronI concure with John. While variations are neat, a large portion of the value of a photo is based on the quality of the image-- whether you're dealing with Old Judges or Greta Garbo photos (I collect Garbo photos). While I don't collect Old Judges, I would never pay big bucks for a photo with a underdeveloped, out of focus or just plain ugly-- even if it shows Joe Jackson in ChiSox uniform. From an investment standpoint, the quality of the image is essential. Remember, when you turn to resell it, the next guy (or gal) is going to say, "but the image is awfuly light."
Having said that, if I were an advanced collector of Old Judges, I would think it cool if not essential to get an example (if inexpensive example) of a pink card along with any other colors available. Consider them type cards.