You don't think Vizquel is a HOFer?
Don Mattingly would not dilute the HOF. He was a HOFer and one of the most talented players ever to play first base. He is so much further up from Andres Gallaraga that they shouldn't be mentioned in the same argument. For reference even with a full career Gallaraga is ranked 70th on the first base list, with Mattingly at 36th.
Injuries didn't ruin Doc Gooden's career either. Doc Gooden ruined Doc Gooden's career.
|