Posted By:
Judge DredJohn,
Nice topic - I used the link you provided and put my two cents in regarding a few 19th century players. I'm sure our lists differ a little bit on the subject. My list of 19th century players that deserve to be in the HOF include Caruthers, Van Haltren and Stovey. Yes, there are others that are deserving like Larry Corcoran (elbow to the ribs and giggle a bit)...
What other 19th century players do other people feel should be enshrined. You have to figure that the HOF is somewhat watered down and that there are more deserving players that should be enshrined while others could be removed (although that wont happen).