Thread: reprint?
View Single Post
  #11  
Old 05-03-2003, 05:46 PM
Archive Archive is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 58,359
Default reprint?

Posted By: Hankron

Firstly and except in blatant cases, I shy away from making a definitive opinion based on the moire pattern in an online image, as modern scanners can do all sorts of funky things. I find it essentiall, if not always possible, to view an item in person before making a final decision.

It has correctly been stated moire patterns are created when making a scan of a card made up of the half-tone dot pattern (ala all those tiny dots in a 1957 Topps or Exhibit card). Lack of a moire pattern doesn't prove anything, as many 1957 Topps or such have been scanned without such a pattern. But if you see such a moire pattern on a Harper's Woodcut or Old Judge or Fatima card, it can be reasonably assumed that the card is a reprint.

I have not seen a T3 in person in some time, and I don't know how they images were made (dots versus no dots). If they don't have the dot pattern, then it would seem unlikely that a moire pattern would appear in a scan of a genuine card.

Note on T206s and related E cards. The half-tone was used differently for these cards, and the half-tone dots (and resulting moire pattern) in the Portrait cards usually appears only in part on the image. So if you see a T206 Portrait and there is moire pattern in the face (for example) but not in the background colors and white borders, this is evidence that the card is gentuine.



Reply With Quote