This card shows Schoeneck in a Chicago Maroons uniform. Somehow the photo was doctored for this Indy card. The "Chicago" has been removed from the jersey, similar to the way some T213 jerseys are altered to reflect "Traded" cards.
In 1888 Schoeneck played 70 games with 287 ABs for the Maroons before moving to the Hoosiers later that year to split time at first base with Dude Esterbrook after the preseason bust at 1B by Walter Bogert.