Quote:
Originally Posted by packs
You're getting into the subjective which is good for discussions. In a subjective world, I would say Derek Jeter was the better player between him and A-Rod. I say that because if I were going to have to choose one player for my team, I would choose Jeter over A-Rod every time.
That's not because Jeter had better stats. It's because I'd rather have him on my team knowing he has attributes you won't necessarily get with A-Rod.
|
many of jeter's attributes are from his POST season play.....if Jeter played ZERO post season games..you would easily pick Arod even if Arod has zero post season games as well...
thus will be the argument against Trout .versus some other lesser stat player but great in postseason.. its always a subjective world until we play real games on paper..