Hard to believe Sisler is in this conversation. Based on others general knowledge of his career and what seems like a lack of interest in his cards compared to many others, I'd put him right smack into the under-rated category.
The guy had some amazing years, with some awful line-ups around him.
OBP is flawed in that it gives walks the exact same relevance as hits. Hits most often move up runners extra bases, not just one base at a time. Sisler was also a Triples machine and stole plenty of bases.
Put the guy in the middle of a Yankees line-up and we'd be paying Gehrig like money for his cards.
|