[Archive]

Posted By: Julie Vognar

favorite vintage: Nichols, Radbourne
non-HOF: Hoy (not quite HOF numbers, but can you imagine a baseball game without signing?), Caruthers
modern HOF: Willie Mays
non-HOF: Pedro Martinez (of course, it's just a matter of time), Kaat (17 Gold Gloves--most pitchers just duck)

As a rule, I'm a pitcher person. Seems to me he's the guy with the most control over the outcome of the game.