Posted By:
MikeU"Mike, the 1914 CJ PSA 3 mathewson sold in 2005 for $25,742 and a PSA4 sold for $40,600 in 2006, maybe VCP doesnt go that far back....search VCP for SGC sales in the last year and you will see what i mean, the last Mathewson SGC didnt come close to $25,000..."
No, VCP does not have the 2005 sale you noted for the PSA 3 1914 CJ Mathewson. It does have the PSA 4 you mentioned. VCP does go back to 2005 for many auctions, but not eBay. In what format did the PSA 3 sell in?
Regardless, the last SGC 40/3 that sold and only one is listed in VCP:
2/26/07 eBay View Auction $22,888.90