Interesting topic, and one that has come to light since Buster Posey's season has come to an end.
Best argument for changing the rules would be the fair catch rule, which protects the kick returner from taking a blind hit. A catcher is equally vulnerable as he can't watch the throw and the runner at the same time.
Best argument against it is catchers would then block the plate entirely, and since the runner wouldn't be allowed to barrell in, he would probably remain on third base unless it was a slam dunk he could score. He would rarely or ever risk what might be a close play. And that would hurt the game.
Maybe there is some nuance they could come up with that would allow the catcher more protection without changing how the game is played.
|