Jackie Robinson and Ted Williams help

[rmarks]

I have been offered in trade the attached 1956 Jackie Robinson and 1969 Ted Williams signed cards. I would be grateful to get your opinions as to the authenticity of the signatures and, of good, their value.

Thanks in advance!IMG_20250902_141856.jpg

IMG_20250902_141905.jpg

[rmarks]

Any expert opinions are appreciated? Thanks in advance.

[mainemule]

Don't like the Ted at all. The d/W connection is terrible imo.

Not sure at all about the Jackie.

[rand1com]

The Robinson is difficult to see due to crossing into the facimile autograph. "Jackie" looks plausible but this is a huge value card if authentic and I would be skeptical that anyone would sell it without being authenticated by a reputable 3rd party. Too much potential money left behind.

I agree the Williams is bad for whatever it is worth.

[mr2686]

Originally Posted by rand1com

The Robinson is difficult to see due to crossing into the facimile autograph. "Jackie" looks plausible but this is a huge value card if authentic and I would be skeptical that anyone would sell it without being authenticated by a reputable 3rd party. Too much potential money left behind.

I agree the Williams is bad for whatever it is worth.

+1

[rmarks]

Thank you for your very helpful comments and suggestions. I am grateful to be a member of the net54 family who look out for each other to ensure the hobby is a safer environment to pursue.